Amazon vs. Shopify for Brands: Choosing the Right Platform

In today’s digital marketplace, brands are no longer limited to just one sales channel. With e-commerce booming, many businesses find themselves weighing the pros and cons of selling on Amazon as a Shopify brand. Both platforms offer distinct advantages, but deciding which is best for your brand or whether you should be using both requires a deeper dive into the Amazon vs Shopify comparison.

This guide will help you understand the Amazon Shopify differences, evaluate your brand’s goals, and learn how an Amazon agency like ours can help you strike the right balance across these two powerhouse platforms.

Starting with the basics…

What is Amazon?

Amazon is a marketplace. When you list your products on Amazon, you’re essentially renting space on one of the world’s largest digital malls. With over 300 million active customer accounts, Amazon gives your products unmatched visibility and access to buyers who are already in a shopping mindset.

What is Shopify?

Shopify, on the other hand, is a platform that allows you to build your online store. It provides the tools and infrastructure to create a branded shopping experience, manage your inventory, and process payments all under your control. With Shopify, you own the relationship with your customer from start to finish.

Selling on Amazon vs Shopify: What’s the Difference?

When making an Amazon vs Shopify comparison, it’s crucial to understand how each impacts your business model, branding, and customer interaction.

1. Brand Control on Shopify vs Amazon

Shopify wins hands down when it comes to brand control. You control your website’s design, layout, and messaging. Your customers experience your brand, not Amazon’s. You can build loyalty, customize promotions, and tailor your marketing efforts to your audience.

Amazon, while powerful, limits your ability to create a unique brand experience. Your listings sit beside competitors, and branding opportunities are minimal unless you enroll in Amazon Brand Registry and invest in A+ content or a storefront. Still, you never quite escape the “Amazon feel.”

Key takeaway: If owning your customer journey and brand image is a priority, Shopify is the stronger choice.

2. Traffic and Audience

Amazon brings the traffic to you. Millions of users search Amazon daily for products. If you optimize your listings correctly and price competitively, your product can get significant exposure with minimal upfront marketing.

With Shopify, you have to generate your traffic. That means investing in SEO, content marketing, paid ads, email campaigns, and social media. It gives you more control but also more responsibility.

Key takeaway: Amazon is ideal for immediate visibility, while Shopify requires long-term investment in marketing.

3. Fees and Costs

Selling on Amazon means dealing with referral fees, fulfillment fees if you use FBA, and additional charges for premium features. These fees can eat into your margins.

Shopify has a monthly subscription fee and payment processing charges, but you keep more of your profits. However, you may need to spend more upfront on design, development, and marketing.

4. Fulfillment and Logistics

Amazon’s Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service is a huge advantage. Amazon stores, picks, packs, and ships your products and handles customer service and returns. This makes scaling easier, especially for smaller teams.

Shopify also offers fulfillment options, like Shopify Fulfillment Network (SFN), but it’s not as mature or widespread as Amazon’s logistics empire.

Key takeaway: Amazon excels in logistics, especially for high-volume sales or international shipping.

Amazon vs Shopify: Who Should Use What?

• New brands looking for fast exposure? Start with Amazon. It helps build initial traction and validate products.
• Established brands with a loyal following? Lean into Shopify to build direct customer relationships.
• Do DTC (Direct-to-Consumer) brands want full control? Shopify gives you total ownership of your store.
• Brands seeking passive traffic and seamless fulfillment? Amazon offers ease and scalability.

But here’s the thing, it doesn’t have to be either-or.

The Omnichannel Approach: Using Both Platforms

Many successful brands are no longer choosing between selling on Amazon vs Shopify; they’re leveraging both. By selling on Amazon, you tap into an existing audience. By owning a Shopify store, you build long-term brand equity and customer relationships.

This dual-channel strategy helps you:

• Diversify revenue streams
• Test pricing, bundling, and messaging
• Capture both organic marketplace traffic and loyal direct shoppers
• Gain insights from both platforms’ analytics tools

However, managing both platforms can be overwhelming, especially if you’re trying to scale.

How SwiftStart Helps You Create the Right Balance

As an experienced Amazon agency, we specialize in helping brands succeed on both Amazon and Shopify without compromising on quality, consistency, or profitability.

Here’s how we support you:

1. Optimized Amazon Listings That Convert

We ensure your product listings are fully optimized with the right keywords, compelling copy, and high-quality images. We handle everything from SEO to A+ Content to ensure maximum visibility and conversions.

2. Amazon Storefront Setup and Brand Registry Support

If you're serious about branding on Amazon, we’ll get you enrolled in Brand Registry and design a custom Amazon Storefront that reflects your identity. It's one of the few ways to stand out on Amazon.

3. Inventory and Fulfillment Strategy

We help you build an efficient inventory strategy that works across both platforms, whether you're using FBA, Shopify Fulfillment Network, or third-party logistics (3PL).

4. Cross-Platform Ad Campaigns

Our team creates and manages ad campaigns on Amazon PPC, Sponsored Products, Shopify, Google, Facebook, and TikTok. The result? A cohesive growth strategy that brings traffic from multiple sources.

5. Data-Driven Insights

We leverage analytics tools from both platforms to guide smarter business decisions from pricing and bundling to customer acquisition and retention.

6. Custom Shopify Store Development

Our designers and developers build beautiful, mobile-optimized Shopify stores that convert visitors into buyers. We integrate email marketing, upsells, loyalty programs, and more.

Amazon vs Shopify Comparison Recap

In the end, the Amazon vs Shopify comparison isn’t about which platform is better, it’s about which one aligns with your goals right now. And if you're ready to go big, combining both is a winning strategy.

Our full-service Amazon agency helps you bridge the gap between these platforms, so you can grow fast on Amazon while building a lasting brand on Shopify. We make sure each platform supports the other, not competes with it.

Ready to find your perfect balance between Shopify and Amazon?
Let’s talk. Our team is here to help you turn your brand into a powerhouse across every channel.

Become A Part of The SwiftStart Community

SwiftStart can help optimize your Amazon listings and supercharge your sales in a jiffy. Swift offers FREE 1 ASIN report (Amazon Listing audit), affordable Image stacking, A+ recharge, SEO Listing, and PPC services to enhance your product listing, visibility, and sales. Moreover, our Amazon Catalogue Course will help you become an experienced Amazon seller.

 

Also, if you want to streamline your brand's operations without hiring an agency, our 450+ Amazon SOP Library is your solution. So, don't miss out on the opportunity. Contact our Amazon agency experts today and take the first step toward elevating your Amazon brand.

Join our social footprint for more Amazon insights and growth hacks. Become a part of our Amazon Community on Skool and subscribe to our popular Amazon newsletter to stay updated with the latest Amazon news, tips, and growth hacks.